On Wednesday, Dec. 5, psychologist Michele Godwin walked into Albrecht Muth’s room in Ward 9 of Saint Elizabeths Hospital, the District’s public psychiatric unit. Over the previous two days, both of them had sat through roughly 12 hours of testimony in D.C. Superior Court about whether or not Muth is competent to stand trial for murder, and Godwin wanted to know how he felt.
Muth told her that he thought his defense team, who had been arguing that he is not competent to stand trial, were doing a good job. Too good a job, maybe, because they seemed to be effectively arguing that he is incompetent and he disagreed.
“He believes the side that says he is competent [the prosecution] will not prevail and that does not make him happy,” Godwin testified in court the following week.
Muth, doctors say, is adamant in his assertion that he is mentally competent and that he wishes to represent himself at trial. But he’s just as adamant that he is an East German spy, a brigadier general in the Iraqi Army, and that the murder of his 91-year-old wife, Viola Drath, for which he has been charged, was an Iranian attempt to assassinate him that went awry.
And therein lies the complicated, confusing, and often convoluted set of facts at the heart of Muth’s mental competency hearing, which lasted more than 35 hours and finally came to an end—though not yet a conclusion—on Wednesday.
Read more